Sanibel Island hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Sanibel Island

Fri 23/2
Tue 27/2
...and more

Let KAYAK do the searching

Save on your next stay

Search and compare hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Sanibel Island

We’re completely free to use – no hidden charges or fees

Latest Sanibel Island Hotel Deals

MOST POPULARSanibel
3+ stars from RM 1,166
Captiva
3+ stars from RM 2,246

Best Sanibel Island hotels

Most recommended Sanibel Island hotels

Show all
Sanibel Island Beach Resort - Sanibel - Bedroom
Sanibel Island Beach Resort
8.5 Very Good
RM 2,323+
RM 2,323+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet-friendly
Tarpon Tale Inn - Sanibel - Patio
Tarpon Tale Inn
9.4 Wonderful
RM 1,839+
RM 1,839+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Sunset Beach Inn
8.6 Very Good
RM 987+
RM 987+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Island Inn
8.9 Very Good
RM 2,826+
RM 2,826+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only
9.4 Wonderful
RM 2,108+
RM 2,108+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Lake Palms 1
RM 1,590+
RM 1,590+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
RM 460+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet-friendly
Seaside Inn
7.5 Good
RM 723+
RM 723+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Song of the Sea
RM 2,769+
RM 2,769+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Shalimar Cottages and Motel
9.4 Wonderful
RM 2,342+
RM 2,342+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool

How much is a Sanibel Island hotel?

Here are our most popular & best value hotels

3 stars

Good to know

Average price (weeknight)

RM 1,584

Average price (weekend night)

RM 2,169
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

When to book a hotel in Sanibel Island

Price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price

Top tips for finding the perfect Sanibel Island hotel

  • If you’re an avid bird watcher, book a stay close to the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge. It is one of the most popular spots in Sanibel Island for watching tall wading birds, including egrets, herons, and ibis, and occasionally, the roseate spoonbill. West Wind Inn on Sanibel Island is one of the best hotels, only minutes away from the sanctuary, and an ideal place to stay if you’re visiting the region for bird watching.
  • The Sanibel Lighthouse is one of the most famous sights on Sanibel Island. If you’re looking to gain some insight into this historic 112-foot-high lighthouse, consider booking a stay at Tarpon Tale Inn. It is only 2min from Lighthouse Beach Park and Sanibel Lighthouse, convenient for people visiting these attractions.
  • Stay close to the water if you’re visiting Sanibel and Captiva Islands on a shelling mission. Staying by the beach allows you to time the low tide, which is usually the best time for shelling. As a general rule, you’ll find smaller shells at the lighthouse end of the island chain and larger shells nearer Captiva. On the lower end of the island chain, some hotels you could consider are Seaside Inn and Sunshine Island Inn. A great by-the-beach hotel in Captiva is South Seas Island Resort.  

FAQs when booking a hotel in Sanibel Island

  • What is the most popular destination in Sanibel Island?

    Based on KAYAK hotel searches, the most popular destination is Sanibel (100% of total searches to Sanibel Island).

  • How much is a cheap hotel in Sanibel Island?

    KAYAK users have found double rooms in Sanibel Island for as cheap as RM 969 (Sanibel) in the last 3 days. The average price is RM 2,166.

  • How much is a hotel in Sanibel Island for tonight?

    In the last 72 hours, users have found Sanibel Island hotels for tonight for as low as RM 1,983 (Sanibel). Users have also found 3-star hotels from RM 1,983 (Sanibel).

  • Where should I stay when visiting Sanibel Island on a fishing trip?

    Sanibel Island has garnered a good reputation because of its fish. Some great fishing spots within the island include Tarpon Bay and Sanibel fishing pier, bayside of Sanibel Lighthouse. The island is rich with fish, and you can even catch some from the beach. If you’re visiting for the fish, book a stay at hotels close to these fishing spots, such as Sanibel Inn and Seaside Inn. Sanibel Inn even allows you to prepare your catch of the day at their outdoor grill and enjoy it with a great view of the bay.

  • Which are the best beach resorts on Sanibel Island?

    Sanibel Island is home to some of the softest sand and most beautiful beaches, and rightly so, beautiful beach resorts. You will find fantastic beach resorts on both Sanibel and Captiva Islands. If you’re looking for a fabulous resort on Captiva Island, check out Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa. A pet-friendly establishment with access to a private beach, outdoor pool, a Jacuzzi, and spa services – everything you need for a great beach holiday. Those on Sanibel Island should love a stay at Sanibel Island Beach Resort, a cozy beach resort only a short drive from Fort Myers, with access to an outdoor pool, private beach, and an in-house bar.

  • How do I find highly reviewed hotels on Sanibel Island?

    You can easily find highly reviewed Sanibel Island hotels on KAYAK. After launching your hotel search on KAYAK, refine your search by review scores. The highly reviewed hotels in Sanibel Island get a score of 9+ or Excellent, usually from previous guests that stayed at the hotels. Some of the highest-rated hotels in Sanibel Island include Tarpon Tale Inn and Island Inn.

Where to stay in Sanibel Island?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Sanibel Island by showing you the exact location of each hotel.